Urgent: vessel in portEN · FR

Ship collision in Türkiye: who pays and how fault is shared

15 October 2026·12 minute read·Updated 15 October 2026
Ship collision in Türkiye: who pays and how fault is shared

A collision between two ships raises one question before any other: who pays for the damage? Turkish law answers it by fault. The Turkish Commercial Code (TCC) has a separate chapter on collision, arts 1286 to 1297, which says who bears the loss when nobody is at fault, when one vessel is at fault and when both are, and treats damage to ships and cargo differently from death and personal injury.

This guide sets out when the collision rules apply, how fault is shared, what changes for cargo on board, for people on board and for pilots, how evidence is preserved, how the claim can be secured against the vessel, how the owner’s right to limit liability fits in, and the time limits.

In brief
  • Where the collision is accidental, due to force majeure or its cause cannot be established, each person bears the loss they suffered (TCC art. 1287(1)).
  • Where one vessel’s owner or crew is at fault, that vessel’s owner must make good the damage (TCC art. 1288).
  • Where both vessels are at fault, their owners are liable for damage to the ships and the goods on board in proportion to the gravity of their fault, in equal proportions if the proportion cannot be fixed or the fault is equal, and their liability to third parties for those claims is not joint (TCC art. 1289(1)).
  • For death, injury or harm to the health of persons on board, the owners of the vessels at fault are jointly and severally liable; between themselves each owner is liable in proportion to the gravity of its fault (TCC art. 1290).
  • No presumption is taken into account in establishing fault in a collision (TCC art. 1294).
  • Every claim for damages based on a collision is time-barred after two years from the day of the collision (TCC art. 1297(1)).

When do the collision rules apply?

The chapter applies to compensation for damage caused to ships, and to persons or property on board, by the collision of two or more ships (TCC art. 1286(1)). It also covers damage done without any contact. Where a ship, by carrying out or failing to carry out a manoeuvre, or by not complying with the rules of navigation, causes damage to another ship or to persons or property on board without a collision, the provisions on collision apply as well (TCC art. 1286(2)).

çatmacollision — TCC art. 1286
The collision of two or more ships; the chapter governs compensation for the damage it causes to ships and to persons or property on board.

Subject to contrary statutory provisions, the maritime provisions of the Code apply to merchant ships (TCC art. 935(1)). The collision chapter reaches further. It also applies to yachts, training ships and other ships assigned solely to leisure, sport, education, teaching or science, and to State ships assigned exclusively to a public service and to warships and auxiliary ships of the navy (TCC art. 935(2)(a)–(b)). The chapter therefore covers a yacht as well as a cargo ship.

No fault, or cause unknown: each side bears its own loss

The Code starts with the case in which nobody can be blamed. Where the collision occurred through an accident or force majeure, or it cannot be established what caused it, the loss suffered by the ships, or by the persons or property on board, is borne by the person who suffered it (TCC art. 1287(1)). The same rule applies where those circumstances arise while all the vessels, or one of them, are at anchor at the time of the accident (TCC art. 1287(2)).

That makes the evidence decisive. A claimant who cannot show what caused the collision does not recover from the other ship under this chapter, because a collision whose cause cannot be established falls within art. 1287(1). The claimant cannot rely on a presumption to fill the gap either.

No presumption is taken into account in establishing fault in a collision.TCC art. 1294

Each party therefore has to prove the fault it alleges. The pre-action survey under art. 1292, described below, records the facts; it does not apportion fault.

One vessel at fault

Where the collision results from the fault of the owner or of the crew of one of the vessels, the owner of that vessel must make good the damage (TCC art. 1288). The rule is addressed to the owner (donatan), whether the fault was its own or that of the people serving on the ship.

This fits the general rule on the owner’s liability for its people. The owner is liable for damage that the crew, a compulsory advisory pilot or a voluntary pilot causes to third parties through fault committed in performing their duties. Towards passengers and cargo interests, however, the owner is liable under the provisions on the carrier’s liability for the fault of the crew (TCC art. 1062(1)). That second sentence matters for cargo carried on board the vessel at fault, discussed further below.

What the chapter does not changeThe provisions on the limitation of the owner’s liability are reserved, and the collision chapter does not affect obligations arising from contracts of carriage or from any other contract (TCC art. 1296(1)). A contractual claim, for instance under a charter or a bill of lading, is decided under its own rules.

Both to blame: damage to ships and cargo

Where the collision results from the fault of the owners or crews of the colliding vessels, the owners are liable for the damage suffered by the ships, or by the goods on board, in proportion to the gravity of their fault (TCC art. 1289(1)). If, in the circumstances, it is not possible to fix that proportion, or it emerges that the parties are equally at fault, they are held liable in equal proportions (TCC art. 1289(1)).

The third sentence of the same paragraph shapes recovery by everyone else. For these claims, the owners’ liability to third parties is not joint (TCC art. 1289(1)). A cargo owner whose goods on one ship were damaged cannot recover the whole loss from either owner; it claims from each owner within that owner’s share of the fault.

  1. Fault. Establish what each vessel and her crew did wrong; no presumption helps either side (TCC art. 1294).
  2. Proportion. Liability for damage to ships and goods on board follows the gravity of each owner’s fault (TCC art. 1289(1)).
  3. Equal shares. If the proportion cannot be fixed, or the parties are equally at fault, they are liable in equal proportions (TCC art. 1289(1)).
  4. Third parties. For these claims the owners are not jointly liable to third parties (TCC art. 1289(1)).

Cargo on board: the navigation and management rule

Cargo carried on one of the colliding ships is in a special position towards its own carrying vessel. Where the collision results from an act of the crew in the navigation or other technical management of the ship, the owner is not liable to the cargo interests in its own ship, under the second sentence of art. 1062(1) and the first sentence of art. 1180(1) (TCC art. 1289(2)).

Art. 1180(1) provides that where damage results from an act relating to the navigation or other technical management of the ship, or from fire, the carrier is liable only for its own fault; measures taken mainly in the interest of the cargo do not count as technical management. In case of doubt, the damage is presumed not to result from technical management (TCC art. 1180(1)–(2)).

The Code then deals with a cargo claimant who sues abroad. If a cargo interest that cannot recover from its own owner because of this exemption obtains compensation for the same damage from another owner at fault under a foreign law, and the owner who paid has recourse against the exempt owner for the part it had to pay in excess, the exempt owner has a right of recourse against that cargo interest in the same proportion (TCC art. 1289(2)).

Recourse has its own clockRecourse between owners under the second sentence of art. 1289(2) is time-barred one year from the date of the payment (TCC art. 1297(2)).

Death and personal injury

For people the Code chooses a different rule. Where the collision results from the fault of the owners or crews of the colliding vessels, the owners of those vessels are jointly and severally liable for the damage arising from the death or injury of persons on board, or harm to their health, caused by the collision (TCC art. 1290(1)). The same paragraph adds that if, in the circumstances, the proportion cannot be established, or it emerges that the parties are equally at fault, the parties are liable in equal proportions.

In recourse between the owners, each owner is liable in proportion to the gravity of its fault (TCC art. 1290(2)). An injured person can therefore claim the whole loss from either owner at fault, and the owner who pays settles the account with the other owner afterwards, within one year from the payment (TCC art. 1297(2)).

  • Passengers. Under the chapter on carriage of passengers, the carrier is liable for loss arising from the death or injury of a passenger caused by a shipping incident, and “shipping incident” includes collision (TCC art. 1256(1), (5)(a)). The carrier is released if it proves that the incident resulted from war, terrorism, civil war, insurrection or a natural phenomenon of an exceptional, inevitable and irresistible character, or wholly from an act or omission of a third party done with intent to cause it (TCC art. 1256(1)).
  • A limit with exceptions. That liability is limited per passenger for each incident to an amount in Special Drawing Rights; a carrier at fault is also liable beyond that amount, and the burden of proving it was not at fault lies on the carrier (TCC art. 1256(1)). Check the figure in force at the time.
  • Contracts preserved. The collision chapter does not affect obligations arising from contracts of carriage (TCC art. 1296(1)).

When a pilot is on board

The Code allocates a pilot’s fault expressly. Where the ship is being navigated by a compulsory advisory pilot (zorunlu danışman kılavuz) or a voluntary pilot (isteğe bağlı kılavuz), the owner of the ship is liable for a collision caused by that pilot’s fault (TCC art. 1291(1)).

The answer changes where the pilot has the conduct of the ship under a compulsory regime. Where the ship is being navigated by a compulsory navigating pilot (zorunlu sevk kılavuzu), the owner is not liable for a collision caused by that pilot’s fault (TCC art. 1291(2)). Which regime applied at the moment of the collision is therefore a question to settle early.

SituationWho bears the damageLiability to othersArticle
Accident, force majeure or cause not established (also where a vessel is at anchor)Each person bears the loss they sufferedNo claim against the other ship under the chapterTCC art. 1287
Fault of one vessel’s owner or crewThe owner of that vessel makes good the damageThat ownerTCC art. 1288
Fault on both sides: ships and goods on boardEach owner in proportion to the gravity of its fault; equal shares if the proportion cannot be fixed or fault is equalNot joint towards third partiesTCC art. 1289(1)
Fault on both sides: death, injury, harm to health of persons on boardRecourse between owners in proportion to the gravity of faultOwners jointly and severally liableTCC art. 1290
Fault of a compulsory advisory pilot or a voluntary pilotThe owner of the shipThe owner of the shipTCC art. 1291(1)
Fault of a compulsory navigating pilotThe owner of the ship is not liable for that collisionNot the ownerTCC art. 1291(2)

Evidence after a collision

Facts about speed, course, lights, signals and the position of each vessel can be preserved before any action is brought. For a pre-action survey of evidence, the competent court is the commercial court of first instance designated for maritime commerce at the place where the collision occurred; failing that, the commercial court of first instance; and failing that, the civil court of first instance hearing commercial cases (TCC art. 1292(1)).

  1. Notice of the survey. The master of every vessel involved in the collision, or his representative, is notified that the survey will be carried out (TCC art. 1292(2)).
  2. No fault percentages. The survey report does not state the proportions of fault of the vessels involved (TCC art. 1292(3)).
  3. No formalities. No notice or other formality has to be completed before an action for collision damage is brought (TCC art. 1293).
  4. Master’s duties. After a collision each master must, where possible without seriously endangering his own ship, crew and passengers, assist the other vessel, her crew and passengers, and, where possible, give the other vessel his ship’s name, port of registry and ports of departure and destination (TCC art. 1295(1)–(2)).

The owner is not liable merely because the master breached the duty in art. 1295 (TCC art. 1295(3)). The survey and the court for the main action are different questions; see our guide Which court for your port? Jurisdiction over a vessel in Türkiye.

Securing the claim against the other ship

The list of maritime claims does not use the word collision. It includes loss or damage caused by the operation of a ship, and loss of life or other personal injury occurring on land or water in direct connection with the operation of a ship (TCC art. 1352(1)(a)–(b)). That a claim is a maritime claim listed in art. 1352 is a ground for arrest (TCC art. 1353(4)), and to secure a maritime claim the ship can only be arrested (TCC art. 1353(1)).

It is sufficient for the claimant to produce evidence that satisfies the court that the claim is one of the maritime claims in art. 1352, and of its money value (TCC art. 1362). The applicant must lodge security in an amount expressed in Special Drawing Rights (TCC art. 1363(1)); check the figure in force at the time.

  • Maritime lien. Claims arising against the owner, charterer, manager or operator for loss of life or other personal injury in direct connection with the operation of the ship, and tort claims for physical loss or damage caused by the operation of the ship (other than loss of or damage to goods, containers and passengers’ effects carried on the ship), give a maritime lien (TCC art. 1320(1)(b), (e)).
  • Exceptions. Those heads give no lien where the damage results from the carriage of oil or other dangerous or noxious substances and is covered by strict liability and compulsory insurance or other security under international conventions or national law, or results from radioactive substances (TCC art. 1320(2)).
  • Turkish law decides. Whether a claim brought in Türkiye gives a maritime lien is determined under Turkish law (TCC art. 1320(3)).
  • Rank. Liens under art. 1320(1)(a)–(e) rank ahead of all statutory and contractual pledges and real encumbrances on the ship, registered or not (TCC art. 1323(1)).
  • Which ship. The ship can be arrested where the claim gives a maritime lien under art. 1320, or where the person who owned her when the claim arose is liable for it and still owns her at the time of the arrest; other ships can be arrested if, when the arrest is made, they belong to the person liable for the claim who, when it arose, was the owner of the ship concerned or her charterer (kiracı), allottee (tahsis olunan) or shipper (taşıtan) (TCC art. 1369(1)(a), (e), (2)).
The lien lapses after one yearThe lien lapses at the end of one year from the date the claim arose, unless before that year has passed the ship has been arrested and, as a result, sold by forced sale (TCC art. 1326(1)). A period in which arrest was not lawfully possible is left out of the calculation; there is no other suspension or interruption (TCC art. 1326(3)).

The arrest procedure is set out in our guide How is a ship arrested in Türkiye, step by step?, the security in What security does the court ask for before arresting a vessel?, and ranking in Maritime liens in Türkiye: which claims follow the ship.

Limitation of liability

Fault decides who pays; limitation can decide how much. The collision chapter expressly reserves the provisions on limitation of the owner’s liability (TCC art. 1296(1)), and the owner’s right to limit its liability under international limitation conventions to which Türkiye is a party is reserved in the article on the owner’s liability for its people (TCC art. 1062(2)).

Which conventionLiability for maritime claims may be limited under the 1976 Convention on Limitation of Liability for Maritime Claims, published in the Official Gazette of 4 June 1980 (No. 17007), together with the Protocol of 2 May 1996 amending it, or under conventions accepted by Türkiye to replace them (TCC art. 1328(1)). Art. 1328 also applies to cases without a foreign element within the meaning of art. 1(1) of the Private International Law Act (TCC art. 1329). The limits are expressed in Special Drawing Rights; check the figure in force at the time.

An owner facing a collision claim therefore has two questions to answer at once: whether its vessel was at fault and in what proportion, and whether and how far it may limit. The claimant has the mirror questions.

Time limits

The collision chapter has its own limitation article. Every kind of claim for damages based on a collision is time-barred after two years, counted from the day the collision occurred (TCC art. 1297(1)). Rights of recourse between owners under the second sentence of art. 1289(2) or under art. 1290(2) are time-barred one year from the date the payment was made (TCC art. 1297(2)).

  1. The claim. Two years from the day of the collision (TCC art. 1297(1)).
  2. Recourse between owners. One year from the date of payment (TCC art. 1297(2)).
  3. The lien. One year from the date the claim arose, unless the ship is arrested within that year and sold by forced sale as a result (TCC art. 1326(1)).
  4. Personal claims. Subject to special provisions in the Code and in other laws, the period in art. 1326 also applies to the creditor’s personal claims against the debtor (TCC art. 1327).

Each rule sits in its own article, so all of these dates are worth noting on the day of the collision. The table of Turkish maritime time bars is in our guide Time bars in Turkish maritime law: the periods to diary.

We advise and act for shipowners and managers, P&I correspondents, hull and cargo insurers, cargo interests and yacht owners after a collision in Turkish waters. The first questions are where the collision happened, who was on the bridge and whether a pilot was navigating, what evidence is still on board, where each vessel is now, and which dates have started to run. See also our page on marine casualties.

Updates to this guide

15 October 2026

Guide published, against the text of TCC arts 935, 1062, 1180, 1256, 1286–1297, 1320, 1323, 1326–1329, 1352, 1353, 1362, 1363 and 1369.

Questions readers ask

Who pays if nobody can prove what caused the collision?

Where the collision occurred through an accident or force majeure, or it cannot be established what caused it, each person bears the loss they suffered (TCC art. 1287(1)). The same applies where those circumstances arise while all the vessels, or one of them, are at anchor (TCC art. 1287(2)). No presumption is taken into account in establishing fault (TCC art. 1294).

If both ships were at fault, can the cargo owner recover everything from one of them?

Not for damage to the ships and the goods on board. Each owner is liable in proportion to the gravity of its fault, in equal proportions if the proportion cannot be fixed or the fault is equal, and the owners’ liability to third parties for these claims is not joint (TCC art. 1289(1)). Where the collision results from an act in the navigation or technical management of the ship, the owner is not liable to the cargo interests in its own ship under arts 1062(1) and 1180(1) (TCC art. 1289(2)).

Is it different for crew or passengers injured in the collision?

Yes. Where the collision results from the fault of the colliding vessels’ owners or crews, the owners are jointly and severally liable for damage arising from the death, injury or harm to the health of persons on board, and between themselves each owner is liable in proportion to the gravity of its fault (TCC art. 1290). A passenger’s claim against the carrier under the contract of carriage is governed by art. 1256, and the collision chapter does not affect contractual obligations (TCC art. 1296(1)).

Is the owner liable when a pilot was navigating the ship?

It depends on the pilot’s status. The owner is liable for a collision caused by the fault of a compulsory advisory pilot or a voluntary pilot navigating the ship (TCC art. 1291(1)), and is not liable for a collision caused by the fault of a compulsory navigating pilot navigating the ship (TCC art. 1291(2)).

Does the collision chapter apply to yachts?

Yes. The collision chapter applies to yachts, training ships and other ships assigned solely to leisure, sport, education, teaching or science, as well as to merchant ships (TCC art. 935(1), (2)(a)). It also applies to damage caused without contact, by a manoeuvre carried out or omitted or by not complying with the rules of navigation (TCC art. 1286(2)).

Can the other ship be arrested in Türkiye for a collision claim?

Loss or damage caused by the operation of a ship, and loss of life or personal injury in direct connection with its operation, are maritime claims (TCC art. 1352(1)(a)–(b)), which is a ground for arrest (TCC art. 1353(4)). Such claims can also give a maritime lien, on the conditions and with the exceptions in art. 1320, and a lien is one ground on which the ship can be arrested (TCC art. 1369(1)(e)). The applicant must lodge security (TCC art. 1363(1)); check the figure in force at the time.

How long is there to bring a collision claim?

Every claim for damages based on a collision is time-barred after two years from the day of the collision; recourse between owners under art. 1289(2), second sentence, or art. 1290(2) is time-barred one year from payment (TCC art. 1297). A maritime lien lapses one year after the claim arose unless the ship has been arrested within that year and sold by forced sale as a result (TCC art. 1326(1)).

Read enough? Send the vessel details and we will say which procedure applies.