Who is liable when a ship causes damage in a Turkish port while a pilot is on board or a tug is assisting? Under the Turkish Commercial Code (TCC), the donatan, the owner operating the ship, is liable for damage that the crew, a compulsory advisory pilot or a voluntary pilot causes to third parties through fault committed in performing their duties (TCC art. 1062(1)). In a collision the ship’s donatan is liable for the fault of a compulsory advisory or voluntary pilot navigating the ship, but not for the fault of a compulsory navigating pilot (TCC art. 1291).
The Code has no chapter on towage contracts: the contract terms and the general rules of the Turkish Code of Obligations are the starting point. This guide sets out how those rules fit together: the pilot categories, the master’s position, the pilot’s own exposure, when a pilot or a tug must be taken in a Turkish port or in the Straits, collisions involving a pilot or the tug itself, how towage is treated, where towage ends and salvage begins, and the limitation, time bar and arrest questions that follow.
- The donatan answers to third parties for the fault of the crew and of a compulsory advisory or voluntary pilot; towards passengers and cargo interests it answers under the rules on the carrier’s liability for crew fault (TCC art. 1062(1)).
- For a collision caused by the fault of a compulsory navigating pilot navigating the ship, the ship’s donatan is not liable (TCC art. 1291(2)).
- The collision rules do not affect obligations arising from contracts of carriage or any other contracts, so obligations under a towage contract are not displaced by them (TCC art. 1296).
Who answers for a pilot’s mistake?
The starting point is the donatan. The Code defines it as an owner who uses its own ship on the water for gain; a person who uses a ship that is not its own on the water for gain, in its own name, personally or through a master, counts as donatan in its relations with third parties (TCC art. 1061). A bareboat charterer that uses the ship on the water for gain in its own name can therefore count as donatan towards third parties.
Art. 1062(1) then makes the donatan liable for damage that the crew, a compulsory advisory pilot or a voluntary pilot causes to third parties through fault committed in performing their duties. Its second sentence changes the measure for two groups: towards passengers and cargo interests, the donatan is liable under the provisions on the carrier’s liability for the fault of the crew (TCC art. 1062(1)). The right to limit liability under the international conventions to which Türkiye is party is reserved (TCC art. 1062(2)).
- zorunlu danışman kılavuzcompulsory advisory pilot — TCC arts 1062, 1291
- One of three pilot categories the Code names. The other two are the isteğe bağlı kılavuz, the voluntary pilot, and the zorunlu sevk kılavuzu, the compulsory navigating pilot. Art. 1062(1) lists only the first two; art. 1291 treats the compulsory navigating pilot differently for collisions.
For cargo carried on the ship itself, the carrier’s rules include art. 1180(1): where the loss results from an act relating to the navigation or other technical management of the ship, or from fire, the carrier is liable only for its own fault. Measures taken mainly in the interest of the cargo do not count as technical management, and in case of doubt the loss is taken not to result from technical management (TCC art. 1180). See our cargo damage claims guide.
Is a pilot in a Turkish port advisory or in control?
The TCC draws the line but does not say which Turkish pilotage service falls on which side. The regulation that governs the service does use advisory language. The Regulation on Pilotage and Towage Services (Kılavuzluk ve Römorkörcülük Hizmetleri Hakkında Yönetmelik, Official Gazette 11 February 2025) defines the pilot as the person who, with the responsibility of the ship’s master as the basis, advises the master on the navigation and manoeuvring of the ship, and defines pilotage as an advisory service given by the pilot for the safe entry, exit or navigation of a ship (Pilotage and Towage Regulation, art. 4(1)(ğ), (h)).
The pilot advises the master on the navigation and manoeuvring of the ship, the master’s responsibility being the basis.Pilotage and Towage Regulation, art. 4(1)(ğ)
That wording is the first text to read when an owner, an insurer or a claimant asks which limb of art. 1291 applies. How a particular pilot is classified on the facts of a particular casualty is for the court hearing the claim; the guide does not predict that outcome. The regulation was adopted under, among other texts, the Ports Law, Law No. 618, whose additional art. 1 places pilotage and towage in Turkish waters with the Ministry of Transport and Infrastructure, which may have them carried out by, or transfer them to, natural or legal persons (Ports Law, additional art. 1).
The master’s position with a pilot on board
The TCC requires the master to act as a prudent master in all matters, in particular in performing the contracts the master has to perform (TCC art. 1088). The master is liable for loss caused through the master’s fault, in particular by failing to perform the master’s duties, to everyone concerned with the ship and the cargo, passengers included; following the donatan’s orders does not relieve the master, and a donatan who gave the order knowing the situation is liable as well (TCC art. 1089(1)–(3)). The master’s own right to limit liability under the conventions is reserved (TCC art. 1089(4)).
The Code uses a similar logic for the master’s own officers. In the presence of danger, a master who consults the ship’s officers is not bound by their decision and remains responsible for the measures taken (TCC art. 1095). No article of the Code applies that rule to the pilot in terms; the Pilotage and Towage Regulation, as quoted above, keeps the master’s responsibility as the basis of pilotage.
Is the pilot personally liable?
Of the TCC provisions that mention pilots, none sets out the pilot’s own liability to the shipowner or to a third party. What the Code does contain is a limitation rule for claims brought against pilots.
Art. 1341(1) sets the limits under the 1976 Convention for all claims made directly against pilots at a total amount in Special Drawing Rights, and art. 1341(2) sets a total limit for recourse claims the owner may bring against a pilot under art. III(5) of the 1992 Liability Convention; check the figures in force at the time. For that article, “pilot” covers the person or persons providing pilotage on board or from anywhere else to the ship, and all natural and legal persons responsible for their acts (TCC art. 1341(3)).
The public law duties run to the authorities. Pilotage and towage providers are responsible to the Administration for performing the service, any contract they make with ship interests or a port facility does not remove that responsibility, and pilots are responsible to the harbour master where the service is given (Pilotage and Towage Regulation, art. 24(1), (14), (22)).
When must a ship take a pilot or a tug?
The compulsory regime is set by regulation and has many exemptions, so the text in force on the day of the call is what matters. Under art. 13(1) of the Ports Regulation (Limanlar Yönetmeliği), the following must take a pilot when berthing at or leaving coastal facilities and fish farms:
- Dangerous cargo. Ships and craft of 500 GT and above carrying dangerous cargo (art. 13(1)(a)).
- Turkish flag. Turkish-flagged ships and craft of 1,000 GT and above (art. 13(1)(b)).
- Foreign flag. Foreign-flagged ships and craft of 500 GT and above (art. 13(1)(c)), foreign-flagged commercial and private yachts of 1,000 GT and above (art. 13(1)(ç)), and all foreign-flagged warships entering or leaving non-military coastal facilities (art. 13(1)(d)).
- Tugs. The minimum number of tugs and their minimum pulling power, by gross tonnage, for ships other than passenger ships are in Annex 5 (art. 13(2)); passenger ships have their own table (art. 14(5)).
Arts 13 and 14 then list exemptions and reductions, for example for some bunkering vessels and for ships with working bow and stern thrusters; read them against the ship’s particulars before assuming either way.
The Straits follow a separate regime. Pilotage and towage during passage through the Istanbul and Çanakkale Straits are carried out by the Directorate General of Coastal Safety (Kıyı Emniyeti Genel Müdürlüğü) under procedures set by the Ministry; natural persons and private law legal persons cannot be authorised for them and the service cannot be procured from them (Ports Law, additional art. 1). The Pilotage and Towage Regulation does not cover that passage (art. 2(3)).
For ships passing through without calling, the traffic centres strongly recommend taking a pilot (Turkish Straits Maritime Traffic Regulation, Türk Boğazları Deniz Trafik Düzeni Yönetmeliği, art. 28(1)). Foreign-flagged merchant ships of any tonnage entering through a Strait for a Marmara port, or leaving one through a Strait, must take a pilot on the sections of the route that the harbour masters consider compulsory (Ports Regulation, art. 14(11)).
Collision with a pilot on board, or with the tug
The collision rules apply to compensation for damage caused to ships, and to persons or goods on board, by two or more ships colliding, and also where a ship, by making or failing to make a manoeuvre or by not complying with the rules of navigation, causes damage without contact to another ship or to persons or goods on board (TCC art. 1286).
If the collision results from the fault of one ship’s donatan or crew, that ship’s donatan must pay (TCC art. 1288); if both are at fault, the donatans are liable for damage to the ships and goods on board in proportion to the degree of their fault, in equal shares where the proportion cannot be fixed or the fault is equal, and not jointly towards third parties for those claims (TCC art. 1289(1)). No presumption is taken into account in establishing fault (TCC art. 1294).
Art. 1291 then allocates the pilot’s fault, and art. 1296 keeps contracts out of the collision rules: they do not affect obligations arising from contracts of carriage or any other contracts. Where the tug and the tow collide, the collision rules and the towage contract therefore have to be read together. See our ship collision guide.
| Situation | Who answers under the TCC | Article |
|---|---|---|
| Damage to third parties by crew fault in performing their duties | The donatan | TCC art. 1062(1) |
| Damage to third parties by a compulsory advisory or voluntary pilot’s fault | The donatan; towards passengers and cargo interests under the carrier rules | TCC art. 1062(1) |
| Collision caused by a compulsory advisory or voluntary pilot navigating the ship | The ship’s donatan | TCC art. 1291(1) |
| Collision caused by a compulsory navigating pilot navigating the ship | Not the ship’s donatan | TCC art. 1291(2) |
| Collision between tug and tow | Collision chapter for ships colliding; obligations under the towage contract are not affected | TCC arts 1286, 1296 |
| Cargo on board, collision caused by a crew act in navigation or technical management | Not the donatan towards the cargo interests on its own ship | TCC art. 1289(2) |
What is towage under Turkish law?
The TCC does not regulate the towage contract as such. Towage and tugs appear in it at three points: unless otherwise agreed, towage charges are among the navigation costs that fall on the carrier alone under a contract of carriage, except for general average and costs of protecting, securing and saving the goods (TCC art. 1196(2), (3)); towage is one of the matters giving rise to a maritime claim (TCC art. 1352(1)(j)); and the crew and other persons serving on a ship or tug assigned to salvage cannot claim a salvage reward or share from the owners of the property saved (TCC art. 1310(5)).
The Pilotage and Towage Regulation defines the towage service as the service given by a tug to assist a ship’s manoeuvres for its safe entry into or exit from a port or waterway, or its safe navigation within a port, waterway or internal waters (Pilotage and Towage Regulation, art. 4(1)(ö)). Towed navigation is outside that regulation, except the berthing and unberthing of the towed ship and stage navigation (art. 2(4)). Between tug owner and tow, the starting points are the contract and the general rules of the Turkish Code of Obligations (TCO).
A debtor that fails to perform, or to perform properly, must make good the creditor’s loss unless it proves that no fault is attributable to it (TCO art. 112). An advance agreement excluding liability for gross fault is void, as is one excluding liability for light fault where a service, profession or art requiring special skill can be carried out only with permission given by law or the competent authorities (TCO art. 115); liability for auxiliary persons can be excluded in advance, subject to the same permission rule (TCO art. 116).
- Who directs the operation. Which party’s master gives the orders during each phase, and what the contract says about it.
- Liability and indemnity clauses. Who bears damage to the tug, to the tow and to third parties, and whether any clause excludes liability for fault (TCO arts 115, 116); whether the permission rules in those articles reach the contract is for the court.
- Limitation. Whether the contract preserves or waives each party’s right to limit (TCC art. 1328).
- Insurance. The regulation requires tugs used in the towage service to have hull and machinery insurance and P&I cover accepted by the Administration (Pilotage and Towage Regulation, art. 24(18)); check what the policies cover.
- Law and forum. The governing law and the court or arbitration clause, read with the arrest rules below.
When does towage become salvage?
Every act or activity undertaken to save a vessel or other property in danger in navigable waters is a salvage operation (TCC art. 1298(1)). Services rendered or to be rendered in performing a contract concluded before the danger arose are not salvage operations (TCC art. 1298(4)(c)). A tug assisting a ship’s berthing under its contract is therefore not a salvor for that work. Services outside that contract are not caught by this exclusion; whether a given service fell inside or outside it is a question of fact.
Services rendered or to be rendered in performing a contract concluded before the danger arose are not salvage operations.TCC art. 1298(4)(c)
Where salvage applies, a salvage operation with a useful result entitles the salvor to a reward, and unless the salvage chapter provides otherwise an operation without a useful result does not (TCC art. 1304(1), (2)). The master may make a contract for the salvage of the vessel on the owner’s behalf, including a choice of court or arbitration (TCC art. 1300(1)). See our salvage guide.
Limitation, time bars and arrest
Liability for maritime claims can be limited under the 1976 Convention on Limitation of Liability for Maritime Claims, the 1996 Protocol, or the international conventions prepared to replace them and accepted by Türkiye (TCC art. 1328(1)). The rights of the donatan and of the master to limit are reserved (TCC arts 1062(2), 1089(4)), and the collision chapter keeps the rules on limiting the donatan’s liability in force (TCC art. 1296). See our limitation of liability guide for the figures and the procedure.
The periods depend on the basis of the claim. Any claim for compensation based on a collision is time-barred in two years from the day of the collision (TCC art. 1297(1)); all claims arising from salvage and wreck removal, whether or not based on a contract, are time-barred in two years, running from the end of the salvage operation or, for wreck removal costs, from completion of the removal (TCC art. 1319(1), (2)). We found no period in the TCC written for towage or pilotage contracts; see our time bars guide.
Towage and pilotage are both maritime claims (TCC art. 1352(1)(j), (k)), and to secure a maritime claim only the arrest of the ship can be ordered (TCC art. 1353(1)). See our ship arrest guide and the ship arrest page.
Evidence after a pilot or tug casualty
Records made in the first days carry the case. The Code and the regulations point to these sources:
- Ship’s log. The pilot’s boarding and leaving times and every accident, recorded day by day (TCC art. 1097(1)(f), (h)).
- Sea protest. After an accident during the voyage concerning the ship or the cargo, or likely to cause other material loss, the master is entitled to request a sea protest and obliged to when asked; the donatan or anyone who proves an interest may also request it, and in Türkiye the courts draw it up (TCC art. 1098(1), (4)).
- Collision evidence. Pre-action evidence is taken by the court designated for maritime commerce at the place of the collision, failing which the commercial court, failing which the civil court hearing commercial cases; the master of each ship involved, or the master’s representative, is notified and the report does not state fault ratios (TCC art. 1292).
- Reports to the harbour master. Those concerned with ships and coastal facilities report marine accidents at once and in writing within twenty-four hours (Ports Regulation, art. 24(1)); in the Straits, pilots report accidents on the ships they are piloting to the traffic centre (Turkish Straits Maritime Traffic Regulation, art. 32(3)).
We advise and act for shipowners, managers, P&I correspondents, hull and cargo insurers, tug operators and cargo interests after a casualty involving a pilot or a tug in Turkish ports and in the Straits. The first questions are who was on board, which pilotage regime applied, what the towage contract says, where each vessel is now and which periods have started to run. See our marine casualties and maritime claims pages.
Updates to this guide
15 November 2026
Guide published, against the text of TCC arts 1061, 1062, 1088, 1089, 1095, 1097, 1098, 1180, 1196, 1286, 1288, 1289, 1291, 1292, 1294, 1296, 1297, 1298, 1300, 1304, 1310, 1319, 1320, 1326, 1328, 1341, 1352, 1353 and 1369, Turkish Code of Obligations arts 112, 115 and 116, Ports Law additional art. 1, the Pilotage and Towage Regulation (11 February 2025), the Ports Regulation and the Turkish Straits Maritime Traffic Regulation.
Questions readers ask
Is the shipowner liable for damage caused by a pilot in a Turkish port?
The donatan is liable for damage that the crew, a compulsory advisory pilot or a voluntary pilot causes to third parties through fault committed in performing their duties; towards passengers and cargo interests it is liable under the rules on the carrier’s liability for crew fault (TCC art. 1062(1)). Its right to limit liability under the conventions to which Türkiye is party is reserved (TCC art. 1062(2)).
Is the owner liable for a collision caused by the pilot’s fault?
It depends on the pilot’s category. The ship’s donatan is liable for a collision caused by the fault of a compulsory advisory pilot or a voluntary pilot navigating the ship (TCC art. 1291(1)), and is not liable for a collision caused by the fault of a compulsory navigating pilot navigating the ship (TCC art. 1291(2)).
Does the master remain responsible with a pilot on board?
The Pilotage and Towage Regulation defines the pilot as a person who advises the master on navigation and manoeuvring, the master’s responsibility being the basis (art. 4(1)(ğ)). Under the TCC the master must act as a prudent master and is liable for loss caused through its fault to everyone concerned with the ship and cargo (TCC arts 1088, 1089(1)).
Must a foreign ship take a pilot in a Turkish port or in the Straits?
Foreign-flagged ships and craft of 500 GT and above must take a pilot when berthing at or leaving coastal facilities, subject to the exemptions in the Ports Regulation (art. 13(1)(c)). For ships passing through the Straits without calling, a pilot is strongly recommended (Turkish Straits Maritime Traffic Regulation, art. 28(1)); foreign-flagged merchant ships of any tonnage entering through a Strait for a Marmara port, or leaving one through a Strait, must take one on the sections the harbour masters consider compulsory (Ports Regulation, art. 14(11)).
Does the Turkish Commercial Code regulate towage contracts?
No. Towage appears in the TCC as a navigation cost borne by the carrier unless otherwise agreed (art. 1196(2), (3)) and as a maritime claim (art. 1352(1)(j)). Between tug and tow the starting points are the contract and the Turkish Code of Obligations, including the limits on clauses excluding liability for fault (TCO arts 112, 115, 116).
Can a tug claim salvage instead of the agreed towage price?
Services rendered under a contract concluded before the danger arose are not salvage operations (TCC art. 1298(4)(c)). Salvage rules apply to acts to save a vessel or other property in danger in navigable waters (TCC art. 1298(1)), so whether a tug’s work went beyond its contract is a question of fact.
